Earnings vs. free cash flow
What many people do not realize is that the company earnings we hear so much about every quarter are really just an accounting concept.
Earnings are a representation of financial reality that emerges from accrual accounting rules.
The purpose of earnings as a financial metric is to provide investors with a snapshot of normalized profitability—one that strips away potentially erratic movements in cash flows.
But there are many adjustments and assumptions that go into it. And these accounting adjustments can often be quite convoluted and arbitrary.
Free cash flow, on the other hand, measures actual cash generation—how much more cash a business has in the register, so to speak, at the end of the day.
Free cash flow can be noisy—but it has the advantage of being highly objective. Cash is cash.
When businesses are "capital light"—meaning they do not require substantial investments in property, plant, and equipment—earnings and free cash flow tend to track each other fairly closely.
But when companies engage in heavy long-term capital spending—as all the major AI hyperscalers are now doing—earnings and free cash flow can diverge dramatically.
So even as leading mega-cap tech companies experience very strong earnings growth, Wall Street is taking a look at their aggressive capital spending trajectories and in many cases pushing back hard.
What exactly is free cash flow—and why does it matter?
Earnings are a useful shorthand to measure financial success. Across the financial media, it is the metric most commonly referenced.
But in the halls of the world’s largest institutional asset managers, free cash flow has always been the subject of much more discussion than many people realize.
The AI spending boom is now bringing this critically important metric to the attention of a much broader audience.
Professional stock analysts spend much of their time trying to decode a company’s financial statements, which are prepared according to Generally Accepted Accounting Principles (GAAP).
The goal is to decipher what is really happening beneath the hood from a cash flow perspective.
Analysts and valuation experts may quibble over what the best way to calculate free cash flow is, but the general idea is that it should measure how much more cash (or less debt) a business is projected to have at the end of a given period versus the beginning.
For example, if a business started the year with a cash balance of $1 million and ended with $1.5 million, it generated $500,000 of free cash flow.
A wide range of factors influence the free cash flow number, such as working capital fluctuations, but usually the biggest one is capital expenditures (or “cap ex”).
Cap ex consists of long-term investments in assets that depress cash flow now but are expected to contribute to cash flow well into the future.
In GAAP earnings calculations, cap ex is addressed through depreciation. A portion of the investment is recorded as a cost every year (depreciation expense) in an attempt to marry the lifespan of the asset to the revenue it generates over time.
For example, a business may make a capital investment in a new truck and depreciate it over a ten year period, rather than book the whole sum as an expense immediately.
This all makes sense if the goal is to generate a fair estimate of run-rate profitability.
Free cash flow calculations, on the other hand, do away with this timing consideration entirely. All that matters is the cash that goes out the door today.
This explains how a company can report substantial profits while generating little or even sharply negative free cash flow.
And it is particularly relevant to the enormous data center construction projects now underway in connection with the multi-trillion dollar AI infrastructure buildout.
These are multi-year projects that are draining resources today on the premise that there will be an attractive future payoff.
Since the tech sector alone now accounts for nearly 40% of the market cap of the S&P 500, whether or not these investments will ultimately succeed may be the most important factor that will determine long-term stock market returns.
Not all cap ex is created equal
There is a crucial aspect of free cash flow that even professional investors often overlook, underappreciate or miscalculate.
One of the most important distinctions in financial analysis is the difference between maintenance cap ex and growth cap ex.
Maintenance cap ex represents investments necessary to preserve a company's existing earning power.
Think of an airline replacing aging aircraft or a manufacturer replacing worn-out machinery. Without these expenditures, the business would eventually deteriorate.
Growth cap ex, on the other hand, represents investments intended to create additional earning power.
Imagine a manufacturer operating ten highly profitable factories that decides to build another ten.
The construction program might consume all the cash generated by the existing operations for several years. Free cash flow could temporarily fall to zero or even become negative.
But would that necessarily mean the company had become less valuable?
Of course not. If the new factories eventually generate attractive returns, the company could become substantially more valuable.
The critical question is not how much cash is being spent, but why is it being spent and what kind of incremental economic return will that spending generate.
Why this matters for AI
The hyperscalers are not replacing existing computers and data centers. They are developing the infrastructure for entirely new products, services, and economic activities.
The vast majority of today's capital spending is intended to create earning power that does not yet exist.
This creates a timing mismatch. The cash expenditures are happening now, but the resulting revenue and profits may not arrive for several years.
Of course, these investments still need to generate returns that justify their cost. Growth cap ex does not automatically create shareholder value.
But a dollar spent maintaining existing earning power is fundamentally different from a dollar spent creating additional earning power. Conventional free cash flow calculations do not distinguish between them.
Are AI companies “buying” their earnings growth?
This brings us to what we consider the most important risk in the current AI spending boom….
To continue reading The Great AI Free Cash Flow Debate, subscribe now to the 76report.
Use promo code DOLLAR and begin for as low as $1 per month.
Click HERE to get started!