Why stocks advanced
The most important explanation for the stock market's positive response is relatively straightforward. Political gridlock is often good for investors.
Democrats may now control Congress, but Republicans still control the White House.
President Trump retains his veto authority, making it extremely difficult for Democrats to implement major new legislation without Republican support. Overriding a presidential veto requires a two-thirds majority in both chambers.
This substantially limits the prospect of sweeping tax increases or other major changes to economic policy that would be harmful to either the stock market or the economy.
Furthermore, much of the administration's economic agenda is already in place.
Tax legislation passed in the current term remains on the books, while the executive branch retains considerable authority over trade, foreign policy, and regulatory matters.
Democrats will certainly exercise their new powers. We should expect investigations, hearings, contentious budget negotiations, and efforts to challenge administration policies.
But the ability to investigate, obstruct or engage in political theatre is very different from the ability to legislate.
Eliminating risks
There is also the simple matter of uncertainty.
Investors spent months anticipating a Democratic takeover without knowing how extensive Republican losses might become. With the results now largely settled, markets can begin looking beyond election probabilities.
During our election-night podcast, NASDAQ futures were down more than 2% as the scale of Democratic gains became apparent, particularly when Abbott's prospects in Texas deteriorated (more on that below).
By Wednesday morning, those losses had reversed.
This is consistent with a historical pattern we highlighted in our election preview. Stocks have generally performed well following midterm elections, regardless of the outcome.
While the fact that the election is over reduces uncertainty generally, investors took additional comfort in Trump’s apparent acceptance of the results and the integrity of the election. In many investors’ minds, that was not necessarily taken for granted given historical precedent.
The market also seemed to interpret the events of the night as reducing one risk in particular—an escalation in the war with Iran.
Oil prices have retreated meaningfully as the Trump administration has communicated the view that the election was ultimately a referendum on the war in Iran.
The market appears to believe the most likely direction of travel at this point from the Trump administration is to reach a diplomatic conclusion. The pubic has spoken, and the administration has received the message.
The decline in spot oil prices suggests this should ultimately bring about a normalization of conditions in the Strait of Hormuz and the potential for a sustained decline in oil prices going forward.
Was it really just Iran?
In a lengthy post on X on Wednesday morning, Vice President JD Vance offered a direct explanation for the Republican defeat—the war in Iran.